Safest Caribbean Islands in 2025: The Ultimate Guide

For those looking to escape to a tranquil and secure paradise, the Caribbean islands offer a welcoming, safe environment that attracts a diverse range of visitors.

What’s more – if you are looking for a second citizenship, there are a number of ways to achieve this in the Caribbean.

In terms of safety, the region is definitely going in the right direction, reaching new heights in the past few years.

Because safety is subjective, we have taken into account data from crowd-sourced organisations such as Numbeo, the United Nations Office on Crime and the travel advisory rating assigned by the US Department of State.

The following Caribbean destinations hold a level 1 advisory rating, indicating they are low-risk and low-crime, where travellers should exercise normal precautions.

Top 9 Safest Caribbean Islands in 2025

St Barts

One of the safest Caribbean islands, St Barts (Saint Barthélemy), boasted a zero homicide rate in 2023 and 2024. In fact, St Barts is considered so safe that you can leave your car unlocked.

Luxurious St Barts is a favourite with celebrities and other wealthy high-end tourists and has an exceptionally low crime rate, with visitors rarely encountering any criminal incidents. 

The latest data reports some property crimes, primarily nonviolent thefts, with any violent crimes involving local disputes rather than tourists.

The small population of about 7,080 means crime is less likely. A high standard of living also reduces social factors driving crime, such as unemployment and poverty.

For extra security, it’s advisable to lock doors and use hotel safes for valuables, as thefts from accommodations, though uncommon, can happen. 

While hurricane season lasts from May to November, serious hurricanes are infrequent, and the island is well-equipped to recover quickly.

Anguilla

Anguilla is known for its stunning beaches and low crime rates. Along with St. Barts, it is one of the safest destinations in the Caribbean.

Popular tourist areas like West End and Sandy Ground are family-friendly with high-end restaurants and resorts, while the East End retains more natural beauty.

While crime exists, it is usually property-related, with very few violent incidents reported. The US Department of State notes that US citizens are not specifically targeted, but it’s wise to remain cautious of vehicle break-ins, burglary and petty theft.

Severe weather is another consideration. Anguilla experiences hurricanes, with an average of one every five years. The hurricane season spans from June to November, so it’s advisable to plan visits outside this period, particularly in September and October.

Grenada 

If you’re considering a move to the Caribbean and prioritise safety, Grenada is one of the top choices. Violent crime is rare, and nonviolent incidents are typically opportunistic.

Both the US and Canadian governments view Grenada as low-risk for travellers, encouraging normal precautions, such as avoiding walking on beaches at night, staying in secure accommodations, and using licensed taxis.

Known for spices and eco-resorts, Grenada offers a unique experience for those interested in nature and is a great choice for expats. 

Beyond tourism, it’s an offshore tax haven with a citizenship-by-investment (CBI) program aimed at those seeking a second passport. Grenada citizenship comes with significant benefits, including a favourable tax environment and easy access to 138 countries, including China and the Schengen area. 

Dominica

Dominica’s commitment to sustainable tourism and conservation fosters a secure environment with local guides who prioritise tourist safety.

Take normal precautions at your accommodation, always lock doors and windows, and use safes for valuables in hotels. If using a rental, ensure the vehicle has insurance. While on boats, remain vigilant against thieves, as yachts can also attract unwanted attention. 

Be aware of potential scams regarding tour and food charges. A 10% VAT may apply but may not always be clearly indicated. 

Dominica is seismically active, with the Morne aux Diables volcano posing a potential tsunami risk. Check your accommodation’s safety plans regarding earthquakes and eruptions.

Hurricane season runs from June to November. If travelling during this time, monitor local weather and heed evacuation warnings as necessary. Dominica has experienced severe storms but fewer than other Caribbean islands.

Antigua

Anguilla is known for its stunning beaches and low crime rates. Along with St Barts, it is one of the safest destinations in the Caribbean.

Popular tourist areas like West End and Sandy Ground are family-friendly, with high-end restaurants and resorts, while the East End retains more natural beauty.

Antigua and Barbuda has gained attention due to its citizenship-by-investment program, favourable tax environment and appealing lifestyle.

Security should be a top consideration for potential residents and investors when choosing a place to relocate or invest. For a more detailed look at this Caribbean Island, see our article: Is Antigua Safe for Tourists, Families, and New Residents?

Cayman Islands

The Cayman Islands also has an impressively low crime rate, along with a friendly atmosphere and a strong focus on safety.

A top family-friendly destination, it is known for its high standards and luxury resorts.

However, it’s still wise to keep your belongings secure and always be aware of your surroundings.

Because of its western geographical location, the Caymans remain in the hurricane zone, but they’re less frequently struck than some eastern islands.

The Cayman Islands has no income, property or company taxes.

So, what are the benefits of obtaining residence in the Cayman Islands? How can you secure a residence permit? Read on to explore your options.

Barbados

Barbados is known for its vibrant culture and energetic Caribbean destination with lively nightlife and bustling markets.  

Its beautiful sandy beaches feature attractions such as Hunte’s Gardens and rum distilleries at St Nicholas Abbey.

Barbados has a low crime rate compared to many of its Caribbean neighbours. It has a level 1 rating, indicating that it’s safe to visit, though minor issues like pickpocketing and scams can occur.

Most crimes affect locals, though violent crime remains a concern, particularly in Bridgetown, the capital. Gangs involved in drug trafficking contribute to most violent incidents, but tourists are rarely affected unless they engage in risky behaviour.

Petty theft is less common than in other tourist destinations, but you should still be cautious, especially during the busy tourist season. Use your hotel safe and keep valuables secure when out and about.

During hurricane season, which runs from June to November, Barbados can experience heavy storms, but is typically on the fringe of hurricane activity.

St Lucia

One of the Caribbean’s safest islands, St Lucia, is known for its lush landscapes and abundant wildlife, attracting visitors with diverse interests.

While petty crimes like larceny and vehicle break-ins can occur, especially in tourist spots, taking simple precautions, such as securing valuables and staying alert, will greatly reduce any risks. Violent crimes, including homicide and robbery, are rare and tend to involve locals rather than tourists.

While hurricanes do pose a risk, many pass by without making landfall. Monitoring the forecast and considering visits outside the June-November hurricane season enhances safety.

Aruba

Aruba’s infrastructure, designed with tourism security in mind, ensures that public spaces, beaches and hotel areas are safe and accessible for everyone.

Aruba, located in the southern Caribbean Sea and part of the Netherlands, is known for its beautiful beaches, dining and shopping options. With year-round trade winds, it enjoys a cooler climate and is one of the safest Caribbean islands, featuring low crime rates. 

While the landscape is arid with cacti and palm trees, tourists can relax as crime is uncommon. 

Most reported crimes are nonviolent, like petty theft and vehicle break-ins. The US State Department classifies Aruba with a safe level 1 travel advisory, recommending that visitors protect their valuables. 

Notably, Aruba is outside the hurricane belt, making it a safe choice during the June to November hurricane season.

Safe Travel in the Caribbean

Even the safest islands have a degree of risk for travellers, so it’s crucial to stay aware of these risks and take precautions:

• Keep your head up and be aware of your surroundings to avoid being caught off-guard.
• Leave expensive items at home or keep them in a hotel safe, and avoid displaying them in public.
• Travel with others, especially at night, and stick to well-lit areas. Be cautious if you are alone.
• Only get into legitimate, marked rental cars and taxis to avoid scams and potential risks with unmarked vehicles.
• Keep money and ID close in front pockets instead of in bags or backpacks to deter pickpockets.
• Familiarise yourself with regulations, as violations can lead to serious consequences. 
• Unforeseen issues like illness or emergencies can arise. Travel insurance helps recover costs if your plans are disrupted.

Residence and Citizenship in Safe Caribbean Islands

As touched on already, the Caribbean offers some of the best and oldest residence by investment and CBI programs.

Grenada CBI

Grenada’s Citizenship by Investment program recently raised its minimum investment requirements, and interested applicants can now choose between two investment options:

• A one-time donation of US$235,000 to Grenada’s National Transformation Fund for a family of an applicant plus three dependents.
• Investors must spend at least US$350,000 for full property ownership and US$270,000 for co-ownership of approved real estate. 

Grenada’s CBI offers numerous advantages, including access to the Schengen Area, the UK, select Latin American nations, and the chance to apply for an E-2 US investor visa.

St Lucia CBI

St Lucia’s Citizenship-by-Investment program goes beyond donations, including government bonds and approved enterprise projects. Investment options include:

• A non-refundable contribution of US$240,000 to the St Lucia National Economic Fund (SLNEF) for a family of up to four.
• Investing at least US$300,000 in pre-approved real estate.
• Investing US$300,000 (plus fees) in bonds for five years.
• Investing a minimum of US$3.5 million in an enterprise project.

St Lucian citizenship offers several advantages, including an extremely fast processing time of just 3-6 months and no need for residency or travel, as the entire process can be completed remotely.

Cayman Islands Residence 

The Cayman Islands offers investors no income, property or corporate taxes.

While getting resident status is relatively straightforward, it does come with significant costs. 

Here are the main options:

• Investing US$1.2 – US$2.4 million in locally developed real estate.
• Investing a minimum of US$1.2 million in a licensed business that generates local employment.

There are plenty of benefits to obtaining residence in the Cayman Islands, especially for high-net-worth individuals.

Dominica Investor Visa         

The Dominican Investor Visa Program, launched in 2020, allows you to gain residency through business investments in Dominica. There are two main options:

• Investing US$50,000 in a government-approved business.
• Invest US$100,000 in a start-up business you control, which must be in an approved economic sector.

Businesses under the second option must create at least three full-time jobs for local workers, though you can seek work permits for specialised roles not available locally. 

Both options require a US$100,000 deposit in a Dominican bank. Additionally, you must spend 90 days each year in Dominica for two years to qualify for citizenship by naturalisation.

The Dominican Investor Visa offers a cost-effective investment option, and unlike citizenship programs, your investment has the potential for returns through business.

If you’re considering settling in the Caribbean, explore the top five CBI programs in our comparison guide. For personalised advice, contact the team at Nomad Capitalist – we’re here to help you find your best destination.

Safest Caribbean Islands in 2025: FAQs

Safe Haven in the Caribbean

If you’re from the US or the UK, your country is actively taking away your rights and privileges. Even your safety is being eroded.

Smaller countries like the islands of the Caribbean may now be the best places for you to get a second citizenship.

British overseas territories, the Cayman Islands and the Turks and Caicos have similar benefits for high-net-worth investors and entrepreneurs, offering little or no taxes.

Antigua and Barbuda, a sovereign state, offers one of the easiest ways to get a second citizenship.

In the Bahamas, you can live a tax-free lifestyle – buy a property and get residency. Its proximity to the US and tax-neutral status appeal to high-net-worth individuals seeking a premier Caribbean base for their assets and lifestyle.

While all CBI locations have something to offer, specific features may appeal to you based on your interests, whether for tax benefits, travel or as a Plan B.

For internationally minded entrepreneurs and investors, personal security is a core pillar of strategic decision-making alongside asset protection, tax efficiency, and legal certainty.

At Nomad Capitalist, we help entrepreneurs and investors create and execute holistic offshore plans so they can go where they are treated best. If you’re ready to take the next step, expert guidance is a conversation away.