Dateline: Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
When I first learned that you could renounce US citizenship, I became fascinated with it.
I never really felt American. I always felt uncomfortable in the US – like I didn’t really fit in.
So when I went on my first big international trip as a young adult to Norway, I started to realize how much happier I could be somewhere else, and I eventually gained the courage to explore those possibilities.
I didn’t start my Nomad Capitalist journey with this kind of tax saving motivation that most people seem to think I had.
While that was certainly an issue that came up (and it’s a perfectly valid reason to renounce), my decision to renounce was more personal.
At first, I wanted to renounce because I was angry at the US. If you read any of my blogs from when I first started Nomad Capitalist, you can see it in my writing. I’d fantasize about renouncing my American citizenship as my own personal form of revenge against the US.
However, over the years, I came to the realization that the US doesn’t need to be my enemy even though it was never really my friend.
When I eventually made my final decision to give up my US citizenship, I went into the process with a clear head, but I was still surprised at a few surprises I encountered along the way.
One thing that I learned pretty quickly was that there are quite a few myths about giving up American citizenship floating around the blogosphere – most of them from people who’ve never actually renounced.
For example, I recently saw someone hosting a masterclass in renouncing US citizenship even though he said he’d never give up his US passport under any circumstances.
If that’s the case, then why was he hosting a whole seminar on the subject?
One thing that I can speak to is that the best knowledge comes from doing – especially in the realm of going offshore and internationalizing your life.
You see, in this business, there are a lot of people who know just enough to be dangerous – they’ve read a few articles or attended a couple of talks about something and think that they know everything.
Some of them are outright scammers, and some of them just theorize for an hourly rate.
That’s why I try so hard to bring transparency to the offshore industry. A big part of my business is dispelling this kind of misinformation and telling people about real, legal ways to solve their problems.
So as someone who’s actually given up my US passport, let’s talk about a few of the myths floating around about giving up American citizenship.
If you’d like more information on renouncing US citizenship, check out our ultimate guide.
Myth 1: You Have to Cut All Financial Ties to the US
One of the main reasons why people hesitate to give up their US citizenship is the mistaken belief that you must cut all of your financial ties to the US if you renounce.
In fact, when I discuss giving up American citizenship with people, one of the first questions they ask is whether they’ll need to close their bank accounts and credit cards or sell all of their US assets.
This myth comes from some of the processes that people in other countries have to go through to become tax non-residents.
Countries that use residential taxation, such as the UK and Canada, require citizens to remove most – if not all – of their assets from the country in order to leave their tax systems.
The US, on the other hand, works a bit differently. Although you need to give up your citizenship to escape the US tax net, you won’t necessarily need to close your bank account or sell your summer home.
In fact, the US actually encourages non-citizens to bank in the US, and if you’re not a US resident, then you won’t need to pay income tax on any interest you accrue on your accounts.
You can also own a home or raw land, and if you own a US company, you can likely keep it if it’s a C-corporation or LLC (S-corporations, however, cannot be owned by non-citizens).
In many cases, you may even be able to keep your US credit cards.
Of course, I can’t speak for all banks and financial institutions – some may decide that they don’t want to deal with non-citizens.
However, if you do decide to renounce your US citizenship, you can have US bank accounts, earn tax-free interest, open certain credit cards, and keep most of your US assets.
Myth 2: You Have to Pay US Taxes for 10 Years After you Leave
Over the years, the IRS has imposed various requirements for people giving up American citizenship.
After a high-profile renunciation in the 90’s upset a number of people, the IRS decided that renunciants shouldn’t be allowed to leave the tax net right away, so they forced anyone who renounced to file and pay taxes for ten years after they left.
Although this rule was in place for a few years, it was later replaced with an exit tax.
However, this exit tax only applies if your net worth is more than $2 million, if you’ve paid a lot in federal taxes over the years, or if you haven’t been compliant with the IRS.
This process is much easier – either you pay an exit tax or your don’t. And, once you’ve filed your final return, you’re finished and can move on with your life.
Myth 3: You Don’t Get Social Security if you Renounce
Contrary to popular belief, you do – in fact – receive your social security benefitsafter giving up US citizenship.
As much as social security is technically a Ponzi scheme, the money that you pay in is technically yours, so the US government will pay it to basically anywhere in the world once the time comes.
Obviously, you won’t be paying into it anymore, but you’ll get what you put in thus far.
However, unless you’ve paid quite a lot into social security, it probably isn’t your largest concern as a six- or seven-figure entrepreneur.
The amount that you’ll likely end up getting is also pretty paltry. I calculated what I’m due to receive, and after over a decade of paying into it, I’ll get a whopping $1,200.
Although you’ll be able to keep your social security, you’ll lose Medicare or other government benefits, such as government or military pensions.
Myth 4: Giving up American Citizenship Means Losing your Social Security Number
When I help others renounce their US citizenship, a handful of questions seem to always come up. One of them is, “what happens to my social security number?”
The answer: nothing.
Even if you renounce, you have your social security number for life.
So, if you go to open a US bank or credit account, you can use your social security number on your application.
As always, you need to be honest with them and tell them that you’re a non-resident alien, but your approval odds will go up if you can provide a social security number.
Myth 5: Renouncing US Citizenship is the Same Thing as Relinquishing it
As regular readers of my blog may know, I frequently write about renouncing US citizenship, not relinquishing it, for one simple reason – renouncing is the process that works for most people.
In fact, of all of the people who I’ve helped renounce, not one of them has been eligible for relinquishment.
However, it is possible to get rid of your US citizenship by relinquishing it.
Relinquishing your citizenship more or less means doing something that causes you to lose your US citizenship.
Renouncing your citizenship, which we often talk about here, is technically a form of relinquishment, but the procedures for formal renunciation and other forms of relinquishment are drastically different.
To renounce your US citizenship, you go to a representative of the US Department of State and make a formal statement that you no longer wish to be a US citizen.
You fill out paperwork, pay the applicable fees, sign an oath, and hand in your passport.
Relinquishing your US citizenship, on the other hand, means performing other expatriating acts, such as joining a foreign military, outside of the presence of a US State Department officer with the clear intention of relinquishing your US citizenship.
After you perform that act, you would then need to apply for a Certificate of Loss of Nationality at the earliest possible opportunity.
Performing a qualifying act of relinquishment, however, is very difficult to do. US courts have set a high bar for what kinds of actions qualify for relinquishment in order to keep it from happening inadvertently.
Because of that, relinquishing US citizenship typically only works in a handful of cases.
Most people who benefit from relinquishment are “Accidental Americans” – people who became US citizens by being born on US soil despite having no real ties to the US. Unless they acknowledged their US citizenship by registering to vote or paying taxes, Accidental Americans can generally prove that they obtained their current nationality with the intention of relinquishing their US citizen status.
Other high-profile cases often involve dual nationals who relinquished their US citizenship to serve in a foreign government or persons who obtained citizenship in a country that does not permit dual citizenship, such as Japan or Singapore.
The main advantage of relinquishment is that it allows you to claim that your US citizenship ended at an earlier date, which can be beneficial in terms of taxation.
However, as with most things in the offshore world, the relinquishment process often gets distorted into some kind of “magic loophole” that allows you to renounce without paying extra fees – even though there’s actually no cost benefit over renouncing.
Unfortunately, I most often hear about relinquishment from people who are trying to game the system to be cute and get out of the US tax net earlier than they could with renouncing.
Unless you’re a part of the very specific group of people that relinquishment applies to, you’ll need to renounce the old fashioned way. The US State Department rarely cuts corners on this matter, so neither should you.
Myth 6: You Can Never Return to the US After you Renounce
Another issue that makes people hesitant about giving up American citizenship is this myth that they can never return to the US if they hand in their passport.
Part of this fear stems from a law called the Reed Amendment, which essentially says that if the US State Department thinks that you left for tax reasons, then it can deny you entry back into the US.
However, this law really hasn’t been successfully implemented.
Although the government could try and pass a more workable version of this law to bar renunciants from returning to the US – and that’s certainly possible given the highly nationalist sentiment in the country right now – the Reed Amendment as it stands isn’t really all that applicable to most people.
In fact, most people who renounce their American citizenship can return to the US rather easily.
One of the few instances in which a former US citizen was denied a visa to the US was the case of Roger Ver — best known as the Bitcoin Jesus after giving away large amounts of Bitcoin — who renounced his US citizenship on his St. Kitts passport. He wrote a huge check for taxes his last year as a US citizen, renounced, and became St. Kittsian.
After renouncing, he applied for a US tourist visa and they wouldn’t give him one. He had a federal criminal conviction, but he claims that they told him that wasn’t the reason he was rejected. The bigger issue, they told him, was that he didn’t have a stable residence.
He was just a perpetual traveler bouncing all around, and US immigration officials tend to prefer some stability. From immigration’s perspective, this does make sense. They could easily be thinking that this guy used to be a US citizen — and he would still be a US citizen if it weren’t for the US taxing him — so why would he leave the country after his tourist visa expired?
So they denied him. They weren’t convinced he would leave the country and return “home” once his stay was up because he really didn’t have home.
Ver’s case, however, is unique, and unless you’re in a unique situation like he was, your level of admissibility to the US is the same as it would be for any other non-citizen in the eyes of the State Department.
If you’re a citizen of a visa waiver country, then you can register with ESTA and be good to go with your tourist visa, and if you have Canadian citizenship, then you don’t even need ESTA.
However, unless you can claim citizenship by descent, the average person is not going to get a passport from one of these countries. If that’s the case, you have to follow another set of rules, and that means you’re going to have to get a visa.
You’re going to need to go to a US embassy, make an appointment, and demonstrate the purpose of your visit just like everyone else.
The State Department won’t be out to get you, but you should make sure that you can qualify for a US visa if you plan on returning to the US after you renounce.
While giving up US citizenship certainly requires some work, it’s not as difficult in terms of cleanup as many people make it out to be.
You don’t need to shut down everything and upend every little aspect of your life that has to do with the US in order to renounce.
This isn’t to say that renouncing is something minor – it’s a big change in and of itself.
However, if you understand these myths, you can make a more informed decision since the process isn’t as confusing as it’s so often made out to be.
Latest posts by Andrew Henderson (see all)
- Will the FATCA Filing Requirement Ever Be Repealed? - May 22, 2019
- The Best Cities for Single Nomads - May 20, 2019
- How to Open a Bank Account in Malta - May 19, 2019