Dateline: Atlantida, Uruguay
A few weeks ago, I met a social media friend in person. She had just arrived in Uruguay, and was planning to spend the next few months in the Maldonado region.
My friend Allison planned to work with with Alex, another social media friend who owned a blueberry farm in the area, and Allison was going help him expand his farm land and develop some exciting, profitable projects.
Unfortunately, upon arriving at his home, she found him lying unconscious. He died a few hours later. The intruders had beaten Alex over the head with a blunt object. But they didn’t steal anything. Not even the cash he kept on his desk. The two suspects — one in his 30’s and the other in his 50’s – were Alex’s employees.
The story went viral in the expat social media community. The prevailing reactions led many to suggest that living in Central America is not safe. I wanted to dispel these notions as, with a few exceptions, living in Latin America is very safe.
Let’s take a few common myths…
Rant: Now is the time to get out. When all hell breaks loose, you don’t want to be a gringo in a Third World country.
Reality: Like it’s easy to be a Jew in Europe, or a US citizen who just happens to be in the wrong movie theater, office building school yard or McDonald’s at the wrong time?
Alex was a Chilean with Argentinean citizenship. Nothing in his appearance spells “gringo.” Furthermore, many people in Uruguay are of European descent. The majority look European, not South American. It’s not easy to find the gringos in Uruguay. And finally, with a 98 percent literacy rate and a thriving tech industry, Uruguay is hardly a Third World country.
Rant: Latin Americans are thieves and untrustworthy.
Reality: As soon as the incident happened, Allison contacted a friend and asked her to contact people from their social media expat group to let them know what was going on. One Uruguayan woman was enjoying a romantic getaway in Paloma. She and her boyfriend jumped in the car and came to Allison’s aid. Another Uruguayan Maldonado local accompanied Allison to the police station and hospital, and acted as a translator. If you choose to move to another country, and then make stereotypes about all of its citizens, perhaps you should leave.
Rant: All of South America is dangerous.
Reality: Most of the crime occurs in the capital city. Here in Uruguay, that means in Montevideo. Crime does happen in the coastal towns, but incidents usually take place during the tourist season and are usually petty in nature.
I won’t try to create a false image of a Latin nirvana. Crime is an issue here as it is in many parts of the world. Everyone has their own comfort level about how much crime – as well as what type of crime – they can deal with.
It depends on who you are, and you’re relocating with.
For example, a fit, 25-year-old male martial arts expert might feel safe in most cities. In contrast, a family with a sexy, precocious teenage daughter might feel uneasy in some Latin American locations. On the other hand, some people will hear about a few incidents and use them as an excuse not to move abroad. To make an informed decision, you need to evaluate the crime scenario, and separate rant from reality.
How to Evaluate Latin American Crime Statistics
Many potential expats simply read the crime statistics, and decide where to live. This type of over-simplification will not help you make informed decisions.
Crime prevention in Latin America involves situational awareness. Unfortunately, the situations in Latin American countries are in a constant state of flux. What was safe yesterday could be unsafe today, and vice versa.
In order to evaluate the safety of any country, city or rural area, you need to understand the who, what, when where, how and why of each situation.
“Who” pertains to who commits the crime, and who are the victims.
“What” defines the specific type of crime. You might be able to deal with the idea of pickpocketing, but rape, murder and home break-ins would qualify as deal-breakers.
“When” refers to both the time of day and the season.
“Where” describes the specific country, city, neighborhood or location.
How do most crimes occur? Pickpocketing is less frightening than gunpoint or knife point. Arson is probably another deal breaker.
“Why” is perhaps the biggest question. Some people say inflation and poverty increases crime. In other cases – as we’ve recently seen in France and the United States – the motivations are political.
When doing your research, look at the big picture. Study the inflation patterns and the increasing or decreasing poverty levels. Learn about the country’s relationship with its immediate neighbors. How does the rest of the world perceive the country?
Here is an overview of the crime situation in the most popular expat destinations. Since I opened this article with an anecdote about Uruguay, let’s start there and examine several expat-friendly countries in South America.
Safety in Uruguay
The Uruguayan government reported 257 homicides in 2014. While this is a relatively low number, Uruguay has seen a 60 percent increase in homicides committed under Mujica’s administration, as compared to the first presidency after the country’s 1984 return to democracy. Then, there’s the juvenile delinquency dilemma.
During the 2014 elections, Uruguay introduced constitutional amendment that would lower the age for criminal responsibility from 18 to 16. This proposal resulted from citizen about the rise in juvenile delinquency; particularly the increase in violent, drug-related crimes during the last decade.
Unfortunately, the amendment failed to receive the required 50 percent of the votes. As such, Uruguayan law continues to confine youth under 18 years old to a juvenile detention facility for a maximum of five years. That’s the bad news.
On the other hand, Uruguay is a secular nation, with strongly defined boundaries between the proverbial Church and State. Religious warfare does not take place in Uruguay, because religious organizations are not allowed to make laws that would affect the lives of those who do not share their beliefs.
As for its military, Uruguay is one of the world’s largest troop-contributing countries to the United Nations peace-keeping missions. Consequently, Uruguay has avoided the hate lists of any country or terrorist organization – even when former president Mujica referred to Cristina Fernandez as an “old hag”. (As we do here.)
Safety In Panama
Many expat publications tout Panama as an ideal expat destination. This Central American country certainly has its benefits, but criminal activity is an issue. Panama’s Public Ministry reports that the country is home to 204 active gangs. However, Insight Crime notes that three successful anti-gang operations occurred in the past few months. As a result, the police arrested 200 people.
In 2014, Panama’s President Juan Carlos Varela introduced the Secure Neighborhoods program, which offered gang members free technical training; as long as they were willing to disarm and integrate with the rest of society.
Still, Panama has a long way to go before it achieves Utopia status. The most dangerous areas in Panama have been said to include Panama Viejo, Cabo Verde, Curundu, San Miguel, Barraza, and Chorillo. These areas have an unacceptable gang activity to police presence ratio.
Safety in Ecuador
Ecuador was the expat’s darling destination of 2014, but is it safe? Limited police resources contribute to the low arrest and conviction rates. Quite often, expats are afraid to report the crime, for fear of retribution.
Many non-violent crimes occur in tourist areas. Thieves will distract a victim by spilling something on them. While one thief attempts to clean it up, his accomplice steals the victim’s pocketbook or wallet.
Then, there’s the express kidnapping. This happens when you get into an unlicensed taxi cab, and the driver takes you to an ATM, holds you up at gun point and makes you liquidate your bank account. It’s happened to two people I know, but expats can largely avoid this and the issue has died down greatly since the early 2000s.
Ecuador expats Bryan and Dena Haines wrote a blog post that identifies the most dangerous sections of Cuenca, where they were actually robbed at gunpoint. Fortunately, action has been taken and the issue is being resolved.
However, what’s interesting about Ecuador – in contrast to Uruguay – is the fact that its coastal areas are more crime-prone than its cities. The results of a research study indicate that expats living in Ecuador’s small towns and rural areas are more vulnerable to crime than those inhabiting cities.
One of the biggest ways to reduce crime on a local basis has shown to be an expat community that gets involved in local events and becomes part of the community. This sounds like a game plan for any expat destination.